(more…)

Dan Quinn was not interested in running the Bucs' defense. (Kim Klement-US PRESSWIRE)

I mention this because Will Muschamp, the coaching wunderkind who once held the keys to the Texas Longhorns as a coach-in-waiting before the Gators pried him from Austin is himself a D-coordinator. Quinn, for all his talent, isn’t truly the guy behind that defense he is at best is a co-coordinator with Muschamp, at worst he’s an administrator of Muschamp’s D.

I know the knee-jerk reaction to this post on Twitter will be that he was a good candidate or that this was a good decision by the Bucs, but I don’t see it. Greg Schiano has never even coordinated in the NFL himself, let alone run a team. It’s incredibly important to bring in experienced coordinators so that Schiano doesn’t have to coach the coaches, Quinn is not an experienced coordinator.

I would say the Buccaneers were looking to be thrifty but Quinn’s salary at UF is a bloated 510 k, so I don’t know he would have necessarily come cheap. I just don’t understand the draw.

Now, don’t take this as me knocking him as a coach, Dan Quinn is a good coach. He deserves that respect. But zoom out for a second, as a candidate with no NFL coordinating experience coming on to the staff of an inexperienced head coach, is that the kind of risk you want to take? Talent aside, that’s a risky foundation with regard to experience.

Butch Davis is a good candidate, he comes with head coaching experience and a great NFL pedigree. Dave Wannstedt (whom Schiano worked under in Chicago and will now run Buffalo’s defense) would have been a great candidate.

But hiring another coach to run the defense who himself has never even been an NFL coordinator is madness. Part of the reason the last staff failed was lack of experience and so far the only known candidates the Bucs have offered jobs to seem to share that lack of qualification.

Dan Quinn did the Bucs a favor on Monday. Don’t weep for this one.

Butch Davis and Randy Shannon are both potential candidates for the Bucs coaching staff. (Bob Donnan-US PRESSWIRE)

As I just mentioned, Mark Dominik maintains final control over coaching hires, but Schiano will have a say and will likely have a number of choices in mind. One possibility, and one group of coaches who may be available (as opposed to those at Rutgers who will be looking to move up at the University) are the men Schiano shares a University of Miami connection with. Like them or not, the Hurricanes have been one of the most prolific college programs, when it comes to creating professionals, that the NFL has ever seen.

If you look at the early 2000′s Miami Hurricanes rosters, upwards of 50 players made it to the NFL, several could be Hall of Famers, and as for current impact, Ed Reed, Frank Gore and Willis McGahee were all on the same roster and factored well into the playoffs (and Gore and McGahee were just back-ups on that roster).

The point is, Butch Davis could recruit, and these men could coach. Now some of them could be candidates to join the staff here in Tampa. Let’s have a look.We’ll break this up into categories based on likelihood. We’ll go with ‘possibilities,’ ‘probably not,’ and ‘downright unlikely, but nice if…’

They should be self explanatory, let’s have a look.

Possibilities

Randy Shannon, Defensive Assistant, Defensive Coordinator

Shannon gets to much grief for his time at Miami. When hired he was handed an academic mandate: clean up the program and improve graduation. He did both. He enforced a curfew, made it against the rules to possess firearms and in his time there more players graduated than ever before and only one arrest occurred during his entire tenure (for which that player was dismissed).

Shannon’s problem was he struggled to recruit outside of Miami and a lot of his more heralded recruits never panned out. From a coaching stand point, Shannon can run one heck of a defense. I think he’d be a better fit as a defensive assistant because he’s never been a coordinator at the NFL level, but he’s done it at college and he coached linebackers for the Dolphins for three years on some very good defenses. He coached a young Zach Thomas for instance. He is currently not working and would probably be a good fit on the Bucs as both a disciplinarian and a developer of young talent.

Ken Dorsey, QB’s Coach

Dorsey is currently a scout for Carolina but he was the quarterback that went 38-2 at Miami and, despite exceptional athleticism, nearly won a Heisman, twice. Dorsey has a brilliant mind, a true student of the game, and would be a phenomenal choice to work with Josh Freeman. He got every last ounce out of his athletic ability and enjoyed a six year NFL career largely because his football intellect was so beneficial to the other quarterbacks on the roster. I’ve read Cleveland and his time with Derek Anderson and Brady Quinn mentioned in particular.

This would be a hire I would be willing to take a wait and see approach with, because I think Dorsey would have a profound impact on Freeman. Dorsey would help Freeman become a better student of the game, would help him develop in the film room and with his reads. He would make Josh Freeman a smarter quarterback. Imagine if Freeman was able to improve his preparation and decision making… with that athleticism he could easily be one of, if not the best quarterback in the league.

Probably Not

Butch Davis, Defensive Coordinator

Davis was the architect of some of the best rosters college football has ever seen. He also was a defensive coach, including a coordinator, for some of the great Cowboys teams of the early 90′s. Like him or not the man can flat out coach.

While I would love see Davis come to Tampa to coach the defense, he’s had a few health issues of late and I’m not sure how anxious he is to jump back into coaching. Should he want to, he would make a phenomenal coach as both a veteran of the NFL and a great X’s and O’s guy and he would take a lot of stress off Schiano. Davis would be my top choice as D-Coordinator. I’m just not sure it’s a likelihood.

Not Going to Happen, But It Would Sure Be Nice…

Rob Chudzinski, Offensive Coordinator

Chudzinski coached tight ends under Butch Davis and took over offensive coordinator responsibilities when Davis left for Cleveland and Schiano took over Rutgers. Chudzinski called the plays when the Hurricanes won their national title. This past year he constructed an offense around Cam Newton that helped the rookie have one of the best rookie seasons in NFL history. He’s a rising star and was considered for the Bucs’ head coaching job.

But he’ll never be on Schiano’s staff because the Panthers would block any attempt to hire him. Unfortunately it would be a lateral move unless he’s the head coach so it’s really never going to get off the ground. Still, this would be an amazing choice to run the offense.

Art Kehoe, Line Coach

Kehoe is the current University of Miami line coach, and the de facto standard bearer for the entire program. More than that though, he coached the line when Schiano ran the defense and has helped developed some of the best NFL offensive linemen of the past three decades. Miami has turned out more pros than anyone since the 1980′s, and the brunt of those linemen were coached by Kehoe.

Unfortunately, Kehoe seems satisfied at Miami. Unless he knows some heavy sanctions are coming down on the Canes or really doesn’t like working for Al Golden, I don’t see him jumping pro.

Mark Stoops, Defensive Backs coach, Defensive Coordinator

Mark Stoops missed Greg Schiano by one year, but helped develop some of the players Schiano coached and recruited, namely Phillip Buchanon, Mike Rumph, Antrel Rolle, Ed Reed and Sean Taylor. If you noticed a pattern those were all first round picks, most are still pretty good pros, and one is a hall of famer. Obviously there’s talent involved, but all cite (or cited, RIP) Stoops as instrumental in their development. Stoops has also been instrumental in building a defense that has been top five in the nation in sacks the past two years at Florida State.

Unfortunately Stoops just took an extension from the Seminoles and his stated ambition is to be a college head coach, but you never know, maybe a chance to coach in the pros could entice him.