The NFC South division is becoming a point of contention around the NFL when it comes to playoff seeding.
Over the last four seasons, the division winner has never won more than 10 games. Twice, an 8-9 record was enough to win the NFC South crown. This year is shaping up to be much of the same, as the Carolina Panthers currently sit atop the standings at 4-5.
While the NFC South teams fight to be the best of the worst, teams like the 7-2 Minnesota Vikings and 7-2 Chicago Bears would be forced to play on the road in the wild-card round under the current system. A potential rule change has been floated that would make it so a team with a losing record can’t host a home playoff game, despite winning their division. Those teams would still make the postseason, of course, but winning a weak division would no longer guarantee you a home playoff game.
That would be a massive mistake for the NFL, and I’m not just saying that because the Tampa Bay Buccaneers have benefitted from playing in the league’s worst division. The proposed rule change would cheapen division rivalries by making the division title less valuable in the playoff structure.
If teams take issue with having to play on the road, there’s a simple solution: win your division.
The NFL needs to rethink its proposed change to playoff seeding
“With the entire NFC South under .500, a year after no one in that division finished .500 and the 8-9 Panthers hosted a home playoff game against the Rams (in which they played quite well, it should be noted), there are rumblings from the league office about reviving the discussion from the 2025 offseason about whether teams that win their divisions with sub-.500 records should be guaranteed home playoff games and top-four seeds in their conference,” wrote ESPN’s Dan Graziano.
It would essentially adopt an NBA-style structure, where conference standings determine seeding and divisions carry little weight.
That approach would be a mistake. The current format rewards teams for winning their divisions, giving them a home playoff game and a top-four seed. Removing that advantage would diminish the importance of division races and rivalries. A late-season showdown between two division contenders simply wouldn’t carry the same significance if the loser could still earn a home playoff game based on its overall record.
The current system is straightforward: win your division, and you host a playoff game. Fall short, and you hit the road as a wild-card team. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. If a wild card team has a better record than a division champion, they should have the opportunity to prove their superiority on the road rather than simply being handed home-field advantage.
The NFL considered the issue during the 2025 offseason, but the proposal, pitched by the Detroit Lions, was shelved after failing to garner enough support. At least 24 of the league’s 32 team owners (75%) must approve a rule change, so hopefully this idea continues to fall short of the necessary votes.
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are proof the NFL shouldn’t change its playoff format
The Buccaneers are a perfect example of why the NFL shouldn’t mess with its current playoff structure. They’ve benefited from winning a weak NFC South division in three of the last four seasons, but they’ve also experienced what it’s like to go on the road against a team with a lesser record.
In 2022, Tampa Bay finished 8-9 but earned the NFC’s fourth seed by winning the NFC South. They lost 31-14 to the fifth-seeded Dallas Cowboys, who finished 12-5. Clearly, the venue in which the game was played didn’t affect Dallas. But under the rule change, the Buccaneers would’ve had to play on the road as the seventh seed.
The following season, Tampa Bay finished 9-8 and again secured the fourth seed. They then hosted the 11-6 Philadelphia Eagles and dismantled them 32-9 to advance in the playoffs.
In 2024, the Buccaneers won the division at 10-7, earning another home playoff game as the fourth seed (notice a trend?). They hosted the 13-4 Washington Commanders and fell 23-20.
Of course, Tampa Bay has also experienced the other side of the equation. In 2020, the Buccaneers finished 11-5 but placed second in the NFC South, forcing them to go on the road against the 7-9 Commanders. There was no complaining about the matchup or venue back then. Tampa Bay simply handled business, pulling off a 31-23 win on the road before eventually going on to win the Super Bowl.
Division rivalries are a huge part of what makes the NFL special. Taking away the home-field advantage attached to a division title would strip those races of some of their significance and punish teams for accomplishing the entire goal of the regular season: winning their division.
Weak divisions aren’t a new problem, and they’re never going away. The answer isn’t to change the playoff structure and cave to the teams who didn’t win their divisions. The NFL should leave the format alone and let division champions keep the advantage they’ve earned.
